Old Crow Medicine Show’s Inaugural Holiday Hootenanny Warms Up Nashville, Indiana

On December 11, 2025, the wonderful lunatics of Old Crow Medicine Show delivered a rousing performance of their first-ever Holiday Hootenanny at the Brown County Music Center in Nashville, Indiana. Marking the band’s debut holiday tour and only the second full show in the series, the night was a perfect blend of foot-stomping bluegrass, classic Christmas tunes, and heartfelt originals. Fans braved the winter chill to fill the venue with energy, singing along to favorites and discovering new seasonal gems from the Grammy-winning group’s new holiday album. If you’re an Old Crow devotee, this show felt like a cozy family reunion with a side of high-energy revelry.

The Band: A Talented Crew of Multi-Instrumentalists

Old Crow Medicine Show, known for their old-time string band sound infused with rock and folk influences, brought their signature vigor to the stage. Founded in 1998, the group has evolved while staying true to their roots. Here’s the current lineup, each member bringing unique flair:

• Ketch Secor – Fiddle, harmonica, guitar, banjo, vocals: Co-founder and charismatic frontman, Secor discovered the incomplete lyrics to “Wagon Wheel” from Bob Dylan’s notes, turning it into a massive hit.

• Morgan Jahnig – Upright bass: Joining in 2000, Jahnig provides the rock-solid backbone with his steady bass lines, anchoring the band’s energetic sound.

• Cory Younts – Mandolin, keyboards, banjo, harmonica, vocals: A member since 2012, Younts adds versatile instrumentation and strong harmonies, drawing from his gospel and bluegrass background.

• Mike Harris – Slide guitar, guitar, mandolin, banjo, dobro, guitjo, vocals: Added in 2022, Harris brings slide expertise and multi-instrumental skills, enhancing the band’s dynamic arrangements.

• Chance McCoy – Vocals, guitar, fiddle, banjo, mandolin, dobro: Joining in 2018, McCoy hails from West Virginia’s Appalachian traditions, infusing authentic mountain music into the mix.

• PJ George – Banjo, accordion, mandolin, fiddle, guitar, guitjo, drums: The newest addition, George is a versatile player who rounds out the group with his broad range of instruments and rhythmic drive.

Special Guest: Bronwyn Keith-Hynes Adds Fiery Fiddle Magic

Guest violinist Bronwyn Keith-Hynes elevated the evening with her award-winning prowess. A Charlottesville, Virginia native who started fiddling at age three, Keith-Hynes has earned two IBMA Fiddle Player of the Year awards and a Grammy for her work with Molly Tuttle & Golden Highway. Her debut vocal album, “I Built a World,” garnered a Grammy nomination, and she’s toured with artists like Dailey & Vincent, Sierra Hull, and the Milk Carton Kids. Her fiery playing and pure vocals blended seamlessly with Old Crow’s style, adding extra sparkle to the holiday set.

The Venue: A Picturesque Spot for Live Music

The Brown County Music Center, a 2,000-seat indoor venue along the serene banks of Salt Creek, offered an intimate setting for the show. Located less than a mile from Indiana’s largest state park and the artsy town of Nashville, it’s a hidden gem with top-notch acoustics and a cozy vibe that made the performance feel personal and immersive.

The Setlist: A Festive Mix of Cheer and Classics

The two-set show kicked off with upbeat holiday numbers and wove in Old Crow staples, building to a joyous finale. Note that this is my copy of the setlist, which I don’t think they modified during the show, but with these fun loving guys, anything is possible.

• Holly Jolly Christmas
• All About The Baby
• 8 Dogs/Breaking Up/ Krampus
• Take Em Away
• I like Beer
• North By Northeast/Kiss Me
• James River Blues
• Grandpa’s Gone
• Dec 26 / Jingle Bells/ Tear it Down
• Happy Xmas (War is Over)
• Intermission
• Trim This Tree
• Candy Cane Habit / (Take A Lick On Me)
• I hear Them All
• (Story)
• Store Bought Christmas
• Sixteen Tons
• Jolly Man
• Holiday Medley
• Corn Whiskey Christmas
• Fairytale of NY
• Wagon Wheel
• Jeremiah (Joy to the world)
• I Saw The Light (religious version, not Todd Rundgren)

Highlights included the rowdy medley of “8 Dogs/Breaking Up/Krampus,” the tender “Happy Xmas (War is Over)” , and the inevitable crowd-pleaser “Wagon Wheel.” Keith-Hynes shone on fiddle-driven tracks, and the band’s storytelling interludes added warmth.

A Night to Remember for Fans

This Holiday Hootenanny captured the spirit of the season with Old Crow’s infectious energy, blending nostalgia, humor, and musical mastery. As one of the early stops in their inaugural holiday tour, it set a high bar for festive fun. Whether you’re a longtime fan or new to their sound, this show was a reminder of why Old Crow Medicine Show remains a beloved force in Americana music. Catch them if you can—it’s pure joy on stage.

Related Posts

• 

  Rock The Country Hits Bellville, TX: A Small-Town Celebration of Music and Freedom
  Rock The Country Hits Bellville, TX: A Small-Town Celebration of Music and Freedom
• 

  Hastings, MI Gets the Rock The Country Treatment: Kid Rock and Jason Aldean Shine
  Hastings, MI Gets the Rock The Country Treatment: Kid Rock and Jason Aldean Shine
• 

  ‘HOME FREE’ HIGHWAYS AND HIGH SEAS TOUR
  ‘HOME FREE’ HIGHWAYS AND HIGH SEAS TOUR
• 

  ALISON KRAUSS & UNION STATION featuring JERRY DOUGLAS
  ALISON KRAUSS & UNION STATION featuring JERRY DOUGLAS

You must be logged in to post a comment Login